Skip to Content

Butt Paste Vs Desitin Daily Defense: What is The Difference?

You wait for ten months for the moment your beautiful bouncing baby makes his or her entrance into the world

and that moment is everything you have ever hoped for and then some.

You spent months preparing for the arrival; you have a crib, and onesies, and hats, and bibs, and bottles, and diapers, and more diapers, and just when you thought there couldn’t be more, you have even more diapers.

You feel ready – finally! And then your little bundle of joy starts crying – really crying.

You realize that in spite of your best-laid plans, your darling dear has gotten a bad case of diaper rash.

Now what?

You have diaper rash cream, but which do you use?

It’s the age-old battle of the best diaper rash cream: Boudreaux’s Butt Paste vs Desitin Daily Defense.

You’re not alone in having a hard time choosing between Butt Paste vs Desitin, but rest assured there is a bona fide diaper rash defender that will keep the diaper rash at bay and have your little darling smiling again before you can say baby!

Butt Paste vs Desitin Daily Defense: What are the key differences to know?

**Some links on this page can take you to, where you can see prices, customer reviews, product specs, etc … Please note that we only share stuff we love. We may earn a small commission if you buy through our links.

Product Satisfaction Rate Review
Desitin Daily Defense diaper rash cream 87% Read Review
Boudreaux's Butt Paste Diaper Rash cream 90% Read Review

They both have the same active ingredient, although Boudreaux’s Butt Paste has a slightly higher amount of zinc oxide.

They both come in several different varieties, ranging from the original, extra strength, and in the case of Boudreaux’s Butt Paste, there is also a “natural” option.

Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is excellent for once a rash has already developed, as it is very thick and encompassing; whereas, Desitin Daily Defense is an apt option for daily, preventive use.

Butt Paste vs Desitin Daily Defense: The Review

Desitin Daily Defense

Desitin Daily Defense Image

Buy From Amazon
Read Customer Reviews Here

Let’s start with the classic.

Desitin has been a go-to family brand for decades, which is probably why you can recognize it easily when you see it on the selves.

This diaper rash cream treats the discomfort, but it can also be used as a preventative measure to keep the rash from occurring in the first place.

This lightweight cream goes on smoothly and is hypoallergenic, so it minimizes the mess and also ensures your baby’s delicate skin won’t become more irritated by your efforts to make him or her feel better.

In addition to its lightweight consistency, Desitin Daily Defense’s primary active ingredient is zinc oxide, which works to relieve the rash within moments of use.

The zinc oxide, combined with the beeswax and petroleum in this cream, moisturize the skin without increasing irritation.

The Desitin Daily Defense is meant for regular use to prevent diaper rash and help with mild to moderate rashes.

Pros of Desitin Daily Defense

The good aspects of Desitin Daily Defense include how lightweight it is and how quickly it sets into effect.

Because it is intended for everyday use, it has an ideal texture than can be wiped off easily and doesn’t get on everything.

It’s also super moisturizing, so you can use it on baby’s knees and elbows or even on your own dry areas!

Desitin Daily Defense is also great because it starts working right away, helping your baby to feel the relief he or she so desperately needs.

Cons of Desitin Daily Defense

If you are not using it as a preventative strategy, Desitin Daily Defense might be a little lackluster.

It is a light cream that is optimal for daily use and just fine for a mild diaper rash

but it might leave you and your little one wanting if the diaper rash is anything worse than at its earliest beginnings.

Boudreaux’s Butt Paste

Boudreaux's Butt Paste Image

Buy From Amazon
Read Customer Reviews Here

There’s a reason Boudreaux’s Butt Paste has found its way into the homes of countless parents around the nation.

Like Desitin Daily Defense, the active ingredient in Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is zinc oxide (read: Fast. Acting. Relief.) Unlike Desitin Daily Defense

however, it contains 3% more zinc oxide and is therefore stronger.

It also lives up to its namesake; it isn’t a cream per se but rather a thick, smooth paste.

It comes in three popular versions including the original, maximum strength, and natural.

Butt Paste can be used as a daily diaper cream, but it’s strength really lies in treating mild to severe diaper rashes.

It locks out moisture that increases irritation by creating a strong barrier on the behind, increasing healing and decreasing the time it takes to have that healing actually start.

“…Nothing worked until we started to used Butt Paste!…” That’s what Vera Sweeney said about Boudreaux’s diaper rash cream. you can watch her video (just below).


Pros of Boudreaux’s Butt Paste

This diaper rash cream works fast and furiously (but is still very gentle).

It goes on strong and keeps your baby’s bottom protected without attacking your nostrils with the pungent odors that are unfortunately often par for the course when it comes to diaper rash creams.

Like Desitin Daily Defense, you can use Boudreaux’s Butt Paste on areas other than a baby’s behind, and it’s completely safe for adults to use as well.

Cons of Boudreaux’s Butt Paste

As you might image, with a name including the word “paste,” Boudreaux’s Butt Paste goes on thick.

It takes a little getting used to as far as actually covering the baby’s bottom with it as well as wiping it off in between changes, so you can reapply it.

It’s definitely strong, but with that strength comes a few dangers – like getting that goop on your clothing.

The paste itself will come out in the wash, but it has also been known to leave its mark, i.e. staining your favorite top.

Still, these cons don’t seem too bad compared to hearing your little love crying out for help.

The Winner

When it comes to actually treating the diaper rash, Boudreaux’s Butt Paste is definitely the way to go.

Desitin Daily Defense is great for preventing the problem, but once it is actually there in full force, Boudreaux’s Butt Paste provides intense relief and alleviates the suffering your baby is inevitably experiencing.

Its active ingredient is stronger than what you’ll find in Desitin Daily Defense, and its dense texture ensures your baby’s butt is covered – literally and figuratively.

At the end of the day, what cream works for your baby won’t be the same as what works for someone else’s baby (or someone else in general, let’s be real here).

Just like everything else in the wonderful world of parenting, choosing the right diaper rash cream for your little one will be a lot of trial and error

but if choosing between these two remedies, you’re bound to find an option that works well for both you and your beautiful baby.

Additional information:

Photo & Video credits: Amazon, vera sweeney.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.